So, I feel I should elaborate a bit more about my decision to remove my name from church records, to resign my membership. It’s a big decision and one that does not come easily.
I have obviously not been active for a long time. I haven’t elaborated much since my last post on this topic many months ago – but I guess for me, once I came to know that I am the person God made me to be, that being gay is not a curse to be overcome, but a blessing, I regained such an overwhelming peace in my life. Which led to the absolute knowledge that what the church teaches about gay people and same sex attraction is wrong. And from there, it was a pretty easy step to see holes in many of the other doctrines and teachings.
I think one of the most surprising things, as the years have passed, is the incredible happiness I have in my life outside the church. Once you are outside of it, it becomes so easy to see how much “mind control” there is in the church. I put that in quotes because I don’t think people are actually being controlled or brainwashed. But there is so much rhetoric about how awful people’s lives are when they leave the church, how they go down this path of sin and they get sick, they lose their loved ones and they die alone. This is not an exaggeration. Just recently someone told me a story of someone who took his name off the church and was subsequently murdered – as if the action brought on the consequence. And when you are inside the church, it’s not like you live with this fear or anything. But it’s still accepted as a fact – people who leave the church are unhappy and tragic things happen to them.
Since I separated myself emotionally from the church, I have come to terms with many issues in my life, I have met and fallen in love with the most incredible person I’ve ever known, I have more financial stability than I’ve ever had in my life, I got a job that finally not only pays me enough to live on but that I really love (I’d never experienced both of those qualities in one job before), I bought a house with my partner – my life is happier than it’s ever been. So I can’t speak for anyone else – but for me, I’ve never been happier than I’ve been outside the church.
I’ve left my name on the records, partly as a concession to my family and partly just out of inertia. I’ve thought about it once or twice, but it was never important enough to go through the process.
But now, after the past few months of activity over Proposition 8 in California, I’ve decided it’s time. It’s no longer honest for me to leave my name on the records of an organization that is actively trying to undermine my relationship and our ability to provide for one another.
I feel very peaceful about the decision itself. But I do feel a lot of anxiety about talking to my immediate family about it. I know people who didn’t feel the need to talk to their families about taking this last step. But I feel that I should, for a couple of reasons.
First, it’s been an important part of my life and I think just writing the letter and sending it almost denies that important role it’s played. I’m leaving, and it’s the right decision, but that doesn’t mean I regret my involvement in the past or that I don’t recognize the role the church has played in making me who I am. (hence, my ‘break-up’ song by the Indigo Girls in my last post – cheesy but how I feel.)
Second, I rarely talk to my family about these issues, and I think it’s only fair that they hear from me about it now and then. I won’t be angry or hurtful when I talk to them and I won’t harp on it afterwards. But I feel that they should know I’m doing it and why. I don’t want them to be able to think that somewhere deep down I still agree with the church or that someday I might change my mind. I want them to know how hurtful the church’s actions and words are for me. But I don’t want them to think I’m asking them to leave the church or disagree with the church. I’m not. But I feel that, as someone they love, I should have an opportunity to tell them how I feel, since the church dominates the rhetoric on this topic. It’s scary, because the church is seen as faultless by its members. So, as much as they love me, they will also think I’m wrong. But I still feel that I need to ask them to consider my feelings and hear me out.
So, my plan is to talk to my mom and my sisters – I don’t need to tell more people than that (although obviously anyone reading this will also know). But I don’t need to “force” the conversation on anyone else. And then I’m just going to continue to live my life.
It’s been a very emotional couple of months. One of our closest couple friends got engaged about a week ago and along with being so incredibly happy for them, I was also sad for us, that we don’t get to do that. But there’s only so much I can do about that. Mainly, I can live my life as openly as possible, so that’s what I will try to continue to do. And hope that we’ll continue to make progress, in courts, in state legislatures and in public opinion.
November 12, 2008 at 2:39 pm
Hi Sheri,
I’m a friend of Brandon’s and we’ve met in the past…I happened upon your blog through Brandon’s blog that I peer pressured him into. I hope you don’t mind that I read this entry and am now commenting. Brandon had the video of Keith Olbermann and I thought it was beautifully said. Brandon said you had shared it with him…which brought me here.
I just wanted to thank you for sharing your story. So often I think that if people knew and understood the pain their actions had on others, they would act differently. I know that having been raised LDS I thought that this issue was black and white. Until I had this amazing person come into my life who shed light on this issue. Knowing Brandon, loving Brandon and understanding more about his feelings have enabled me to see beyond the black and white. Although I am still an active member of the LDS church, I will never turn my back on Brandon or any other person simply because they are gay. And I would hope that he would never turn his back on me for being straight.
Nor would I choose to vote against you have the right to marry the person you love most.
To me…saying you’re gay is merely stating a part of you. It’s like saying what color eyes you have. It is simply you, it is who you are and it doesn’t change what rights you should have. Nor does it make you better or worse than someone else. We are all people, equal regardless of who we fall in love with.
We may not always agree on how everyone should live their life. But I do think that everyone has the right to fully live their life. And fully living your life means having full rights, the same as anyone else.
Brandon is an amazing man, he will make a wonderful dad someday. And I don’t think anyone should be denied the right to marriage and children based on who they love. Unless it’s Gilbert Gottfried. I think we can all agree that he shouldn’t procreate. The same rights I have should be extended to Brandon, and to you and to everyone else out there.
I am thankful that you are able to express yourself and share your story. I am hoping that more people will try to understand one another and realize that we are all different, yet we are all the same. We all seek love, and we should all be allowed the right to cherish love and create a family.
So, I’m LDS, my best friend is gay and I think he should be allowed to marry and have children…where does that leave me? Hopefully it leaves me as a voice of reason and love and compassion for those around me who are a part of the church. And hopefully it leaves me as someone who can be a branch of hope for you and for Brandon and for others out there who are struggling with the church’s stance on this. I do believe you have to live the life you are meant to live. And I commend you for living as honestly and as openly as you can. I am hoping that someday my children will play with Brandon’s children and this will not be an issue in their lives. That there will be no difference.
I hope this all came out the way I intended it to. I just wanted to thank you for being you and sharing that with others. I really do believe that gay marriage and equal rights are on the horizon. And hopefully sharing and understanding can get us there faster. Thanks Sheri.
November 12, 2008 at 9:17 pm
Hey Lisa,
I’m glad you stopped by – and of course I don’t mind you reading and commenting. If I did, I shouldn’t be blogging in the first place, right?
I really appreciate what you said – and I think that is the way that change will come. It will probably be slower and more painful than some of us would wish but I think being ourselves around the people we love can only have good effects. The fact that your relationship with Brandon has given you a perspective on this issue that maybe a lot of your brothers and sisters in the church don’t have is invaluable and I’m proud of both you and Brandon for the example you are setting for all of the rest of us.
I think you re right – it’s on the horizon. This is a setback, but eventually people’s hearts will soften.
Thanks for sharing your experience! And thanks for keeping Brandon in line!
Sheri
November 25, 2008 at 8:32 pm
Dear Sheri,
My desire for you is that you find true joy in this life. I love you for the wonderful person that you are.
I love you dearly!
Love and hugs,
Aunt Jeri
November 25, 2008 at 11:39 pm
Hi Aunt Jeri,
I have to admit, I was a little nervous when I saw I had a comment from you. But I made the decision to write pretty honestly here, and that means letting those who will read it see a little more clearly who I am and how I’ve gotten here. But I appreciate knowing I have your love. Thank you for letting me know that. I love you too and all your kids. You have raised an awesome family! Thanks for your love and example!
Love you,
sheri